Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Scientists Warn of Dangers of Hydrogen: Harsh Climate Consequences

Climate consequences of hydrogen emissions

Listen to the Podcast:

Hydrogen is a clean and efficient fuel. When burned, it does not emit carbon dioxide or other air pollutants. It can also be used in fuel cells to create electricity, and its only waste is water. It can be produced from renewable sources, such as solar or wind power, making it an attractive option for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

It presents some challenges, such as the large amount of energy required for its production and the difficulty in storing and transporting it, given its low energy density and its tendency to leak from containers. It also requires advanced technologies to extract its full energy potential.

Despite these challenges, there are several sectors where hydrogen is already being used as a fuel, such as in public and private transportation, industry, and power generation. As technology improves and costs fall, hydrogen is likely to become an increasingly important part of the global energy mix.

And this is a Problem?

“Hydrogen is theoretically the fuel of the future,” says Matteo Bertagni, a postdoctoral researcher at the High Meadows Environmental Institute. “However, in practice, it raises many environmental and technological concerns that need to be addressed.”

Hydrogen readily reacts in the atmosphere with the same molecule responsible for breaking down methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas. If the level of hydrogen emissions exceeds a specific threshold, this reaction is likely to cause a buildup of methane in the atmosphere, which will have long-term climate consequences.

Bertagni is the lead author of a research paper published in Nature Communications explaining the effect of hydrogen emissions on atmospheric methane. Above a certain threshold, in the theoretical case that it replaces the use of fossil fuels, a hydrogen-based economy could cause short-term environmental damage by increasing the amount of methane in the atmosphere.

The risk is given by the leaks that its storage can produce. The damage is compounded by hydrogen production methods that sometimes require the use of methane. To obtain pure hydrogen, it is necessary to extract it from the compounds in which it is part of or combined, mainly water, fossil fuels, and organic matter. This conclusion highlights the critical need to manage and minimize emissions during hydrogen production.

“We have a lot to learn about the consequences of using hydrogen so that the switch to an apparently clean fuel does not create new environmental challenges,” warns Amilcare Porporato, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the High Meadows Environmental Institute.

The Chemistry of Hydrogen

The problem boils down to a small, difficult-to-measure molecule known as a hydroxyl (OH) radical. It has often been referred to as “the detergent of the troposphere” because it plays a key role in removing greenhouse gases such as methane and ozone from the atmosphere.

The hydroxyl radical also reacts with gaseous hydrogen in the atmosphere. Since a limited amount of OH is generated each day, any increase in hydrogen emissions means that it would be used to break down hydrogen, leaving less available to break down methane. As a consequence, methane would stay longer in the atmosphere, extending its impact on warming.

According to Bertagni, the effects of a peak in hydrogen production could have climate consequences for the planet for decades. “If some hydrogen is emitted into the atmosphere now, it will lead to a progressive buildup of methane in the following years,” explains Bertagni. “Although hydrogen only has a lifetime of around two years in the atmosphere, the methane feedback from that hydrogen would last for another 30 years.”

In the study, the researchers identified the tipping point at which hydrogen emissions would lead to an increase in atmospheric methane, calling into question some of the short-term benefits of hydrogen as a clean fuel. By identifying that threshold, the researchers were able to set targets to help manage hydrogen emissions. “It is imperative that we be proactive in setting thresholds for hydrogen emissions to use in the design and implementation of future hydrogen infrastructure,” says Porporato.

Green and Blue Hydrogen

In the case of green hydrogen, produced by the electrolysis of water, dividing it into hydrogen and oxygen, and using renewable energy sources, Bertagni sets the critical threshold for hydrogen emissions at around 9%. This means that if more than 9% of the produced hydrogen leaks into the atmosphere, either at the point of production, at some point during transport, or at any other time along its value chain, atmospheric methane would increase over the next few decades.

In the case of blue hydrogen, produced from natural gas by capturing and storing carbon dioxide (CO2) instead of releasing it into the atmosphere, the emissions threshold is even lower. Because methane itself is a primary feedstock, blue hydrogen producers must consider direct methane leakage in addition to hydrogen leakage. For example, the researchers found that even with a methane leak rate as low as 0.5%, hydrogen would have to be kept below 4.5% to avoid rising methane concentrations in the pipeline and atmosphere.

Therefore, managing hydrogen and methane leak rates will be critical. According to Bertagni, “A small methane and hydrogen leak would make using blue hydrogen no better than using fossil fuels, at least for the next 20 to 30 years.”

Control Measures

The research emphasizes the importance of the time scale on which the effect of hydrogen on atmospheric methane is considered. In the long term, in a century, for example, the shift to a hydrogen economy would generate net benefits for the climate, even exceeding the levels of methane and hydrogen leakage. Bertagni explains that “eventually, atmospheric gas concentrations would reach a new equilibrium, and the shift to a hydrogen economy would demonstrate its climate benefits.” However, before that happens, the possible consequences will be seen “in the short term since hydrogen emissions could cause irreparable environmental and socioeconomic damage.”

Therefore, if institutions are to meet mid-century climate goals, hydrogen and methane leaks into the atmosphere must be controlled as hydrogen infrastructure begins to roll out. Because hydrogen is a small molecule that is difficult to control and measure, managing emissions will require researchers to develop better methods to track hydrogen losses throughout the value chain, Bertagni adds.

“If companies and governments are serious about investing money to develop hydrogen as a resource, they need to make sure they do it correctly and efficiently,” concludes Bertagni. “Ultimately, the hydrogen economy must be built in a way that does not offset the efforts of other sectors to mitigate carbon emissions.”


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Related Articles

Top Trending

First Global Summit on Artificial Intelligence in UK
Anthropic Unveils AI Powerhouse: A New Challenger to ChatGPT Emerges
Bedroom Design Ideas
7 Bedroom Design Ideas to Boost Mental Health
Artificial Intelligence Blessing or Curse
AI Unveiled: Boon or Bane for the Future [Expert Insights]
javaughn j. porter
Javaughn J. Porter: A Look into the Life of Blueface's Son
PO Box 7250 Sioux Falls SD
Unlocking The Mystery of PO Box 7250 Sioux Falls SD

LIFESTYLE

Top Surnames American countries
Discover the Top Surname in Every American Country [2024 Update]
Taurine Key to Extending Life Research Finds
Taurine: The Secret Ingredient for a Longer Life? Latest Research Insights
Strategies to Beat Procrastination
Beat Procrastination: Effective Strategies to Stay Productive!
Egyptian Cotton Sheets for Your Bed
A Beginner's Guide to Choosing the Perfect Egyptian Cotton Sheets for Your Bed
Long Lehenga Choli
Elegance Redefined: Navigating the Diverse World of Long Lehenga Choli Designs

Entertainment

javaughn j. porter
Javaughn J. Porter: A Look into the Life of Blueface's Son
turk lesnar
The Relationship of Turk Lesnar With His Father Brock Lesnar [Untold Story]
Uncensored Anime
15 Best Uncensored Animes to Watch in 2024 [Ranked]
Taylor Swift Shares Emotional Singapore Connection
Taylor Swift Shares Emotional Singapore Connection on Eras Tour
Ugly Movie Characters
15 Most Ugly Movie Characters You Have Ever Seen [Ranked]

GAMING

Nintendo lawsuit Rhode Island Game Piracy
Nintendo Takes Legal Action Against Rhode Island Company Over Game Piracy Claims
Best Online Pokies in Australia
The Best Online Pokies in Australia
Sports Betting vs Online Casinos
Sports Betting vs Online Casinos: Where is it Easier to Win?
Play Games for Bitcoin
Can You Play Games for Bitcoin? 
Most Played Games at Online Casinos
Discover the Most Played Games at Online Casinos

BUSINESS

Bitcoin to Ethereum, Discover how Brazil is embracing cryptocurrencies
Leverage Trading Crypto: A Comprehensive Guide for Beginners and Advanced Traders
Popular is Crypto
The Ultimate Cryptocurrency Trading Strategy for Beginners: A Step-by-Step Guide
Crypto Trading Bots
Crypto Trading Bots: The Ultimate Guide to Automated Cryptocurrency Trading
Crypto Futures Trading
Crypto Futures Trading: Beginner-Friendly Strategies and Advice
Best Crypto Trading App in 2024
The Best Crypto Trading App in 2024: Top Mobile Platforms for Cryptocurrency Exchange

TECHNOLOGY

Sam Altman Clarifies no Ai Creatures in Development
OpenAI's Sam Altman Clarifies: No AI "Creatures" in Development
Spotify Epic Vs Apple DMA Compliance
Spotify & Epic Claim Apple's App Store Fails to Meet DMA Standards
Technology Reshaping Share Market
How Technology is Reshaping the Share Market Investing Landscape?
Integra Sources
Integra Sources: Custom Project Development Services
Sam Altman OpenAI Investigation Investor Claims
OpenAI & Sam Altman Probe: Investor Mislead Claims Amidst Leadership Turmoil

HEALTH

CDC Advice
New CDC Advice: Seniors Should Get 2nd Updated COVID Shot Now!
Tata Institute Rs 100 Cancer prevention Tablet
Tata Institute's Breakthrough: Rs 100 Tablet May Prevent Cancer Recurrence
Norovirus Cases Surge US Northeast CDC Report
US Norovirus Surge: CDC Highlights Spike in Northeast Cases
Top Healthiest and Unhealthiest Countries
Top Healthiest and Unhealthiest Countries Globally - 2024 Rankings
Best Way to Prevent Gum Disease
What is the Best Way to Prevent Gum Disease?