Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

Harvey Weinstein’s Rape Conviction Reversed on Appeal

Harvey weinstein rape conviction overturned

The Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, has overturned Harvey Weinstein’s conviction for rape in New York in a stunning reversal.

This decision opens the door for a potential retrial of the disgraced former Hollywood mogul.

The 4-3 ruling centered on the trial court’s decision to admit testimony from women whose allegations were not directly part of the criminal charges against Weinstein. The court found this testimony prejudiced the jury and deprived Weinstein of a fair trial.

“We conclude that the trial court erroneously admitted testimony of uncharged, alleged prior sexual acts against persons other than the complainants of the underlying crimes because that testimony served no material non-propensity purpose,” the majority opinion stated.

Judge Jenny Rivera, writing for the majority, called the errors “egregious” and said the appropriate remedy is a new trial. This means Weinstein’s accusers could be called to testify again if prosecutors decide to retry the case.

The decision has shocked the #MeToo movement, which began in 2017 with the initial allegations against Weinstein. Many of his accusers have expressed dismay and concern over potential retraumatization from another trial.

“All of the fear and the panic and the confusion from the original trauma comes back,” said Louise Godbold, who accused Weinstein of assaulting her twice in 1991. “Our truth isn’t overturned, even if his conviction is overturned.”

Caitlin Dulany, who alleged Weinstein assaulted her in 1996, said she was “deeply shocked” and saddened by the decision. Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, who recorded Weinstein apologizing for groping her, highlighted the systemic failures in the justice system.

Some legal experts have criticized the ruling, with Judge Madeline Singas accusing the majority of “whitewashing the facts” and failing to recognize the jury’s ability to consider Weinstein’s past acts. Attorney Douglas H. Wigdor called it a “tragic” step back that could deter sexual assault victims from coming forward.

Tarana Burke, the founder of #MeToo, underscored the importance of the movement, stating, “Moments like this underscore why movements are necessary.” 

Actress Ashley Judd, one of the first Weinstein accusers, declared she stands “shoulder to shoulder with women who have bloody knees because male sexual violence may knock us down, but we get right back up.”

The decision comes as Weinstein, now 72, is already serving a 23-year sentence in New York for criminal sexual act and third-degree rape convictions.

He was also convicted of rape in Los Angeles in 2022 and sentenced to 16 years in prison, though his attorneys expressed confidence that conviction will be upheld.

The Manhattan District Attorney’s office has vowed to “do everything in our power to retry this case,” setting the stage for a potential second battle in the courtroom and further reckoning with Weinstein’s alleged crimes.

As the legal process continues, the ruling has reignited discussions around fair trials, admissibility of evidence, and the ongoing struggle for justice and accountability in sexual assault cases. The reverberations of this decision are likely to be felt far beyond Weinstein’s individual case.

The Information is Collected from NBC News, Axios and ABC News


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Related Articles

Top Trending

Hamas Rejects Israel Ceasefire Deal
Hamas Rejects Israel Ceasefire Deal Amid Gaza Escalation
netflix 2025 q1 results revenue up 13 percent
Netflix Surpasses Q1 Forecast with 13% Revenue Growth
Israeli Airstrikes Kill Displaced Palestinians in Gaza
Israeli Airstrikes Kill Displaced Palestinians in Gaza Tents Blaze
katy perry bezos fiancee not real astronauts
Trump Official Says Katy Perry, Bezos’ Fiancée Not Real Astronauts
selena gomez x rated photo background shocks fans
Selena Gomez Leaves Fans Shocked by Risqué Photo Background

LIFESTYLE

12 Budget-Friendly Activities That Won’t Cost a Penny
12 Fun and Budget-Friendly Activities That Are Completely Free
lovelolablog code
Unlock Exclusive Lovelolablog Code For Discount Deals in 2025
Sustainable Kiwi Beauty Products
10 Sustainable Kiwi Beauty Products You Should Try for a Greener Routine
Best E-Bikes for Seniors
Best E-Bikes for Seniors with Comfort and Safety in Mind
wellhealthorganic.com effective natural beauty tips
Top 5 Well Health Organic Beauty Tips for Glowing Skin

Entertainment

netflix 2025 q1 results revenue up 13 percent
Netflix Surpasses Q1 Forecast with 13% Revenue Growth
selena gomez x rated photo background shocks fans
Selena Gomez Leaves Fans Shocked by Risqué Photo Background
xqc net worth
XQc Net Worth Reaches $50 Million By 2025: A Streamer's Success Story
itzhak ezratti net worth
Itzhak Ezratti Net Worth in 2025: Behind GL Homes Growth
nicholas riccio net worth
Nicholas Riccio Net Worth: From Homeless to Millionaire With Karoline Leavitt

GAMING

Which Skins Do Pro Players Use Most Often
Which Skins Do Pro Players Use Most Often in 2025?
Major Security Risks When Visiting iGaming Platforms
12 Major Security Risks When Visiting iGaming Platforms (And Proper Remedies)
Familiarity with Online Casino Games Builds Gameplay Confidence
How Familiarity with Online Casino Games Builds Gameplay Confidence?
Pixel Art Games
Why Pixel Art Games Are Still Thriving in 2025?
Most Unfair Levels In Gaming History
The Most Unfair Levels In Gaming History

BUSINESS

IRA Rollover vs Transfer
IRA Rollover vs Transfer: Key Differences, Benefits, and Choosing the Right Option
optimizing money6x real estate
Money6x Real Estate: The Power of Real Estate Without the Headaches
Crypto Tax Strategies for Investor
Don't Miss Out: Learn the Top 15 Crypto Tax Strategies for Investors in 2025
Flexible Trailer Leasing
How Flexible Trailer Leasing Supports Seasonal Demand and Inventory Surges?
Importance Of Continuous Compliance Monitoring
Understanding The Importance Of Continuous Compliance Monitoring

TECHNOLOGY

katy perry bezos fiancee not real astronauts
Trump Official Says Katy Perry, Bezos’ Fiancée Not Real Astronauts
Platforms Offering Money-Back Guarantees And Free Trials
Top 10 Platforms Offering Money-Back Guarantees And Free Trials
Best Web3 VPNs For Secure And Private Browsing
10 Best Web3 VPNs For Secure And Private Browsing
openai launches advanced ai models and coding agent
OpenAI Launches New Reasoning Models and Coding Agent for Developers
Gemini Live camera screen sharing android
Gemini Live Camera and Screen Sharing Now Available to All Android Users

HEALTH

How to Start a Mental Wellness Program at Work
How to Start a Mental Wellness Program at Your Office?
Tips For Mentally Healthy Leadership
10 Tips For Mentally Healthy Leadership
Back Pain In Athletes
Back Pain In Athletes: Prevention And Recovery Strategies
Sinclair Method
What is the Sinclair Method?
Small Things Neurologists Wish You’d Do For Your Brain
10 Small Things Neurologists Wish You’d Do For Your Brain