Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

We Already Have the Means to Stop Overfishing, Why Are Politicians Dragging Their Heels

UK fishing bans to curb overfishing

  • Nearly half of the United Kingdom’s maritime ecosystems are threatened by overfishing, while the government sets catch limits that ignore this reality.
  • Examples from around the world debunk ideas that installing a fishing ban is either not feasible, or that it will destroy the fishing industry and communities that rely on fishing.
  • Technological innovations such as Dahua video surveillance with parking hydrological detection already exist to serve the UK’s specific needs in overfishing.

A September 2023 report by Oceana brought to light disturbing news: nearly half of the United Kingdom’s fish populations are at risk of overfishing or critical depletion. This alarming predicament largely arises from government-set catch limits that exceed scientific recommendations.

In response to an article published by the Guardian, the UK government cites reforms aimed at modernising ‘outdated’ EU common fisheries policy, assuring readers of their commitment to heeding scientific guidance. However, amidst these assurances, it becomes evident that British politicians are reluctant to take more decisive action.

Comparatively, other nations such as Mexico and areas closer to home such as the Isle of Arran in Scotland have taken the bold step of implementing outright fishing bans in areas witnessing continuous declines in endangered fish populations. This raises pressing questions about the UK’s stance on safeguarding its marine ecosystems.

There are numerous misconceptions regarding fishing bans, from feasibility of such a move over vast amounts of sea surrounding our island nation to the effect on the fishing industry in a country that runs on fish and chips. This article sheds light on these misconceptions, backed by the scientific evidence upon which the UK government aims to base its policies.

The first key misconception is that fishing bans are not realistic in the UK. They have already been implemented in the UK on a much smaller scale. On Lamlash Bay in Arran, a ‘no-take zone’ has been helped marine life recover exponentially, with Scottish National Party Minister Ariane Burgess describing the effects as an ‘underwater triumph’.

Some may point to the difference in scale, with Arran being a small island and the wider UK being a much larger endeavour. This is not as insurmountable as one may think. When fishing bans are localised to small areas that are affected by overfishing more acutely, compliance with fishing bans can be enforced through video surveillance. 

The technology to do this already exists. Surveillance systems such as those produced by Dahua Technology can utilise parking hydrological detection, taking into account water level, boat detection, and floating object detection to identify the presence of large objects that is disrupting the natural flow of water. 

From land, powerful zoom capabilities can then examine boats to determine their purpose, giving those who are enforcing fishing bans the right information to evaluate whether the ship’s presence is allowed or not, and to decide on appropriate action.

The second misconception regarding fishing bans is that fishing industries would greatly suffer and that jobs would be lost. When fishing bans are localised to areas that see the most worrying trends in marine life, it allows for populations to grow in the long term, and in the short term, areas that are not seeing large scale depletion of aquatic life can continue to be fished following scientific guidelines. 

A study of a Mexican marine park debunked the myth that fishing bans harm catch volumes. The Revillagigedo national park ban had minimal economic impact on the fishing industry, showing protected areas can promote sustainable and equitable ocean use. Compliance with the ban was high, and there was no significant displacement of fishing activity. 

The study also highlighted the decline in illegal fishing and the potential benefits of protected marine areas. Researchers are currently exploring fish populations in the park and advocate for more marine protected areas to meet global conservation goals. 

This means that the fishing industry will not be decimated by fishing bans, and that those Friday fish and chip dinners do not have to be outlawed to protect marine life. It also will not lead to massive job loss, and instead offers hope to the fishing industry, and the sustainability of those ecosystems is directly linked to the sustainability of jobs and livelihoods within communities that rely on fishing.

In the wake of Oceana’s important report regarding the precarious state of the UK’s fish populations, it is clear that bold action is imperative to prevent overfishing and preserve our marine ecosystems. While the government’s commitment to reforming the fisheries policy is commendable, it is essential to address the reluctance to take decisive measures.

Looking to examples from Scotland and Mexico demonstrate the effectiveness of fishing bans in curbing overfishing without crippling their fishing industries. The misconceptions that such bans are impractical in the UK or damaging to its fishing industries are debunked when considering the potential for local video surveillance to enforce targeted measures and the long-term benefits that short-term fishing bans have for the fishing industry.

It is high time for the UK government to shed misconceptions, embrace innovation, and be resolute in its commitment to sustainable fisheries. By doing so, we can secure the future of our oceans while still enjoying our beloved fish and chips. The health of our marine ecosystems and our fishing industry depends on it.

You May Find Interest: From Ocean to Stall: How Fish Vendors Achieves Unprecedented Seafood Visibility?


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Related Articles

Top Trending

patricia sue peterson
What Really Happened to Michael Peterson's First Wife Patricia Sue Peterson?
February 24 Zodiac
February 24 Zodiac: The Ultimate Astrology Profile and Forecast
How To Block Subreddits
Google's $60M Deal with Reddit for AI Content Use: What It Means
Best Hiking Trails in Europe
20 Best Breathtaking Hiking Trails Across Europe Revealed
is terrifier based on a true story
Exploring the Truth: Is 'Terrifier' Truly Based on a Real Story?

LIFESTYLE

Egyptian Cotton Sheets for Your Bed
A Beginner's Guide to Choosing the Perfect Egyptian Cotton Sheets for Your Bed
Long Lehenga Choli
Elegance Redefined: Navigating the Diverse World of Long Lehenga Choli Designs
valentines day outfits
Top 20 Trendy Valentine's Day Outfits in 2024 For Every Occasion
eldritch foundry
Unleash Your Imagination With Eldritch Foundry Custom Miniatures
jayda wayda braids
How Long Do Jayda Wayda Braids Last [Durability and Maintenance Tips]

Entertainment

is terrifier based on a true story
Exploring the Truth: Is 'Terrifier' Truly Based on a Real Story?
losmovies alternatives
180 LosMovies Alternatives for Watching Movies and Series in 2024
cartoon characters with big noses
20 Famous Cartoon Characters with Big Noses of All Time [Ranked]
Gillian Anderson and David Duchovny
Gillian Anderson and David Duchovny Reunite and Reflect on Their X-Files Legacy
Lewis Gratz Fell
The Mysterious Life and Death of Lewis Gratz Fell: Aileen Wuornos' Ex-Husband

GAMING

Crypto Gambling Innovations
Innovations in Crypto Gambling: Shaping the Future of Online Betting
User Experience Design in Online Casinos
The Role of User Experience Design in Online Casino Platforms
New Online Service for Fans of Sports Betting and Casino Games
A New Online Service for Fans of Sports Betting and Casino Games
Are Online Gaming Bonuses Worth Pursuing
Are Online Gaming Bonuses Worth Pursuing These Days?
why does turles look like goku
Why Does Turles Look Like Goku: The Saiyan Secret Explained

BUSINESS

Work Life Balance Europe vs America Comparison
Europe vs America: Decoding Work-Life Balance Differences
Romania 28th Place EMEA Private Companies Ranking
Romania Rises to 28th in Top EMEA Destinations for Private Firms - PwC
Employee Advocacy
The Role of Employee Advocacy in Enhancing Your Online Reputation
Top 10 World's Wealthiest Men
Top 10 World's Wealthiest Men: 2024 Rankings Revealed
Complexities of Pricing Algorithms
Navigating the Complexities of Pricing Algorithms

TECHNOLOGY

How To Block Subreddits
Google's $60M Deal with Reddit for AI Content Use: What It Means
Google Gemini Conversations Stored Years Default
Google Halts Gemini AI Image Tool Over Historical Inaccuracy Concerns
Why Digital Fax Services Outshine Traditional Fax Machines
7 Reasons Why Digital Fax Services Outshine Traditional Fax Machines
apple launch sports app
Apple Launches Exciting New App for Sports Enthusiasts: Get the Details!
Generative AI in Adobe Acrobat
Generative AI in Adobe Acrobat: Chat Seamlessly with Documents!

HEALTH

Brain Stimulation RTMS vs DTMS
Decoding Brain Stimulation Therapies: RTMS vs DTMS Explained
Top 10 Easy Stress & Anxiety Relief Techniques
Top 10 Easy Stress & Anxiety Relief Techniques - Find Calm Fast
Advantages and Challenges of Using Peptides
Advantages and Challenges of Using Peptides in Medicine Manufacturing
Long Covid Impact Millions Children Pregnant Studies
Studies Reveal: Long Covid Affects Millions, Including Kids & Pregnant Individuals
How Egyptian cotton sheets can improve your health
A Good Night’s Sleep: How Egyptian Cotton Sheets Can Improve Your Health