Austin Butler, best known for his Oscar-nominated performance as Elvis Presley in Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis (2022), has once again shocked fans and critics alike—this time with a dramatic physical transformation for his upcoming role in Caught Stealing, a gritty crime thriller directed by the acclaimed Darren Aronofsky.
The trailer for the film dropped this week and quickly started trending across social media platforms, sparking a wave of fan reactions and renewed buzz around Butler’s range and dedication as an actor.
From Rock ‘n’ Roll Royalty to Gritty Criminal Underworld
In Caught Stealing, Butler plays Hank Thompson, a once-promising high school baseball player whose future was derailed by a career-ending injury. Now living in New York City in the 1990s and working as a bartender in the East Village, Hank is just trying to get by. But his quiet life takes a dangerous turn when he agrees to cat-sit for his eccentric neighbor Russ (reportedly played by Matt Smith), who is described as a punk-rock musician with secrets of his own.
What seems like an innocent favor becomes a gateway into a violent and unpredictable underworld. Hank soon finds himself at the center of a dangerous plot involving stolen money, violent criminals, and double-crosses. The character’s descent from washed-up athlete to desperate survivor has been compared to the style of gritty noir thrillers, something that fits Aronofsky’s intense directorial style perfectly.
The film is adapted from Charlie Huston’s 2004 cult novel of the same name, a darkly comic and brutal story that blends crime, absurdity, and survival. It marks Aronofsky’s return to high-stakes psychological thrillers after his recent acclaimed films like The Whale and Black Swan.
Butler’s Shocking Physical Transformation
Fans quickly noticed that Butler looks significantly more muscular and rugged in the film, showcasing a lean but powerful build that reflects the physical demands of the role. The transformation has sparked a flurry of online discussion.
“AUSTIN BUTLER THE HOT MAN YOU ARE,” one X (formerly Twitter) user wrote while sharing a scene from the film.
AUSTIN BUTLER THE HOT MAN YOU ARE pic.twitter.com/vnKig00sQ3
— 𝑮𝒂𝒃𝒔 (@abutlersz) May 21, 2025
“I’m telling you, he’s the next Brad Pitt,” another user commented, referencing Butler’s rising star power and onscreen presence.
Butler is no stranger to method acting. For Elvis, he reportedly stayed in character even when off-camera and studied Presley for over two years. He’s continued that dedication here, not only changing his physical appearance but also reportedly immersing himself in the 1990s New York aesthetic, language, and attitude required for the role.
Zoe Kravitz, Matt Smith, and More Star in Ensemble Cast
Joining Butler is an impressive cast that includes:
- Zoë Kravitz as Hank’s love interest, Yvonne, who becomes entangled in the escalating danger.
- Matt Smith as Russ, the cat-owning punk neighbor who sets off the chain of events.
- Regina King, Liev Schreiber, Vincent D’Onofrio, Carol Kane, and even Bad Bunny in a key supporting role.
The ensemble lends serious weight to the project, with each actor taking on roles that reflect the chaotic criminal ecosystem of 1990s New York. According to Vanity Fair, Aronofsky wanted to build a world that felt both heightened and grounded—a fever dream of danger, music, and desperation.
A Gritty, Stylized Look at 1990s New York
Caught Stealing is set in a raw, stylized version of New York City, captured in all its chaotic beauty during the early ’90s—a time before smartphones, social media, and surveillance culture. Think dimly lit bars, alleys drenched in neon, and apartment buildings full of mystery.
The film’s cinematography, teased in the official trailer, shows off Darren Aronofsky’s signature visual intensity—quick cuts, intimate camera angles, and atmospheric lighting. The setting serves as both a backdrop and a character itself, reflecting Hank’s descent into a life he never asked for.
Notably, some viewers took issue with the film not using Jane’s Addiction’s 1990 hit song “Been Caught Stealing,” which many expected to feature in the soundtrack due to the film’s title. While the track doesn’t appear in the trailer, it’s not confirmed whether it might be included in the final release.
Mixed Reactions Online, But Buzz Remains High
While the buzz has largely been positive, some users on social media weren’t completely sold on the film. One critic commented, “Looks generic, boring, trying to be cool. Pass,” suggesting the trailer didn’t do enough to differentiate it from similar neo-noir thrillers.
Still, the majority of responses have leaned toward excitement, with praise directed at Butler’s new look, the compelling trailer, and the film’s intense atmosphere. Some fans joked that they would be watching just for the plot, sharing steamy stills of Butler and Kravitz in a close embrace.
Release Date and What to Expect
Caught Stealing is scheduled to hit theaters on August 29, 2025, distributed by Paramount Pictures. With a powerhouse director, a stacked cast, and a gripping premise based on a cult-favorite novel, the film is shaping up to be one of the most anticipated late-summer releases.
Whether you’re a fan of Butler’s previous work, a lover of intense thrillers, or just curious to see Aronofsky’s latest vision come to life, Caught Stealing promises to deliver a raw, visceral ride through the darker corners of one of the world’s most iconic cities.
